Benchwatch

People released from custody who were later charged with a violent crime

Each case names the judge or agency that made the release decision, the terms of release, and what happened next, with links to the news reports and court records it draws on.

Cases
25
Judges and agencies named
25
Median days from release to the new crime
94

Cases

Newest first
Kate Steinle
Victim
Jose Inez Garcia Zarate
Defendant
Shooting in San Francisco, California

Kate Steinle, 32

July 1, 2015, 77 days after release
Sanctuary policyUndocumented
Prior arrests
7
Released April 15, 2015 by Ross Mirkarimi (Sheriff at time)
ICE detainer declined per SF sanctuary ordinance

Steinle was walking on Pier 14 with her father when she was struck in the back by a bullet that ricocheted off the concrete. Garcia Zarate said he found the gun (stolen from a federal agent's vehicle) wrapped in cloth under a bench and that it discharged accidentally. Acquitted of murder/manslaughter in 2017; convicted in federal court of being a felon in possession. Sentenced to time served.